Mission Statements Reflection

I was curious about whether schools reflected their mission statement values in their admissions decisions. To do so, I focused primarily on diversity and secondarily on community service. Diversity can be represented in multiple ways, including economic and racial. I first looked at economic diversity in the student body because I expect money to have more potential to distract schools from their values. The school reported to have the most economic diversity in their student body is University of California, Los Angeles.1 Interestingly, UCLA ranked second in racial diversity,2 demonstrating consistency in their commitment to diversity.

Looking at UCLA’s mission statement, it does go beyond academia by citing service as a core value. The school’s short-and-sweet version of their mission statement reads: “UCLA’s core mission can be expressed in just three words: Education, Research, Service.”3 By accepting a student body that is more diverse, they themselves are performing a service to their community and have better empowered themselves to have a broader impact on society. This value of outreach resonates in their longer-version mission statement, which begins: “UCLA’s primary purpose as a public research university is the creation, dissemination, preservation and application of knowledge for the betterment of our global society. To fulfill this mission, UCLA is committed to academic freedom in its fullest terms: We value open access to information, free and lively debate conducted with mutual respect for individuals, and freedom from intolerance. In all of our pursuits, we strive at once for excellence and diversity, recognizing that openness and inclusion produce true quality. These values underlie our three institutional responsibilities.” It is reassuring to see that their admissions process supports their drive to promote diversity, inclusion, and dissemination of education. Their extracurricular offerings and student body appear to similarly give back to society, as UCLA is ranked #8 in outreach and community service.4

The university with the least economic diversity in their student body is Washington University in St. Louis.5 One fifth of this school’s student population is from the top 1% of earners, while just 6% of their student body comes from the bottom 60% of earners in the US. Their racial diversity is not ranked as low, but amongst the top 100 schools for academics in the US, they rank a very middling 43.2 However, their mission statement also promotes diversity. Their opening sentence says: “Washington University in St. Louis’ mission is to discover and disseminate knowledge, and protect the freedom of inquiry through research, teaching and learning.”6 This statement is quite similar to UCLA’s, purporting dissemination of knowledge and freedom of learning and research too. The school also aims to “strive to enhance the lives and livelihoods of students, the people of the greater St. Louis community, the country and the world.” Additionally, their first goal is “to welcome students, faculty and staff from all backgrounds to create an inclusive community that is welcoming, nurturing and intellectually rigorous.” However, if they really were to be inclusive of their local community and beyond, their student body would need to be more representative of these populations.

Interestingly, WashU does rank very high in service opportunities and community mindedness. They ranked #11, citing specifically that students spend a high proportion of time participating in community service activities.4 Perhaps through reading personal essays or paying attention to extracurricular activities from applications, admissions committees did place high value on students with an interest in outreach. It would be less hypocritical, though, if the school offered the opportunity it presents for social mobility to students from a wider diversity of backgrounds.

 

1https://www.usnews.com/best-colleges/rankings/national-universities/economic-diversity-among-top-ranked-schools

2https://priceonomics.com/ranking-the-most-and-least-diverse-colleges-in/

3http://www.ucla.edu/about/mission-and-values

4https://www.bestvalueschools.com/non-profit-and-community-service-ranked-by-return/

5https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2017/01/18/upshot/some-colleges-have-more-students-from-the-top-1-percent-than-the-bottom-60.html

6https://wustl.edu/about/mission-statement/

2 Replies to “Mission Statements Reflection”

  1. This blog illustrates the exact reason I’ve always held mission statements from organizations with a heavy lens of skepticism. A organization’s mission statement can be whatever they want, but if they do not back up that with action it is meaningless words. However, you looked at economic diversity amongst a school’s student body and I agree that its very important, but how did either school fare with other forms of diversity? Were their claims backed up by the proportions of minorities they accepted? To be truly considered diverse I would be inclined to think they should be representative of all forms of diversity.

  2. I like how you did some research to see if these mission statements were backed up by facts. I don’t think a lot of people (including myself) did that. For me mission statements don’t always express the current state of the university, but maybe a goal they want to maintain or reach. It sounds like UCLA has reached and maintains that goal while WashU hasn’t done such a good job. I don’t know much about the process of accepting students (both grad and undergrad) into a university from the faculty view, but it’d be interesting to see what exactly affects their choices and if the mission statement pushes them in particular directions.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.