My experience with grading systems

The reading materials regarding assessment this week reminded me of my school days. I have taken grading or ranking for granted quite a long time because I only experienced that kind of assessment since I entered into the regular school curriculum in Korea. I hadn’t recognized it as a problem much, but looking back, the ranking system made not only teachers have preconceptions about each student, but also students form social groups according to their grades. The students were generally classified into model students who study well and poor students who don’t study well. The focus of teachers and schools was more on the former because the school’s reputation and success are evaluated by how many students go to top universities. This test score-oriented educational atmosphere was also prevailing amongst students. They tended to socialize each other whose ranks are similar because sometimes top students studied separately with others. I assume this grade-focused assessment in school might affect widespread prejudice and discrimination in various fields of Korean society.

On the other hand, from the perspective of a parent of a Kindergarten kid, I admit that sometimes grading assessment makes me easier to identify how my child has been improving briefly and clearly. When I first received my son’s first report card last year, it helped me to understand which subject he needs to help and he is doing well. But without teachers’ narrative comments and conference, it must be difficult to know how to help him to improve some abilities (even though Alfie Kohn pointed out the inefficiency of adding narrative reports).  Another thing I was not able to figure out through his report card was his interests or talent of physical activities, music, or art because it was more about his literacy, math, and sociability.

Although grading must be the easiest and simplest way of assessment of academic achievement, it does not correspond to the primary goal of education as well as assessment. Assessment needs to play a role in discovering and improving students’ interests, capabilities, and talents, not harming them. As more and more innovative endeavors are being carried out in schools, I hope better assessment tools will be developed and spread out.

5 Replies to “My experience with grading systems”

  1. It will certainly be difficult to get away from using grades as a form of assessment. It is the easiest method we have of forcing students to do the work and understanding how well their understood it. However, there is certainly a disconnect between learning and our current assessment methods. It doesn’t make students learn more, if anything, it makes them find the easiest way out of doing an assignment because they find no personal enjoyment out of the material.

  2. Hey Kyunghee, I completely relate to your experience with school curriculum because we have the same thing in India (Intelligent students and poor students). In face we had separate sections according to marks. So 90% and above in A section, 75% to 90% in B , 60 % to 75% in C and rest all in D and It did create a bias. I was in section A and we used to get the best teachers and we were favored by all the teachers. This created a hatred among the other section students against us and we could feel that. Now, that I think of it, such an environment was not healthy, not for most students. I think systems like these need to change for good. Thanks for the post.

  3. Thanks for the post, Kyunghee. This is exactly what happens in India. It definitely creates a divide which is not healthy. Also, the prime focus of the student becomes good grades and not the learning/knowledge. This needs to change for sure.

  4. Good stuff Kyunghee. I really liked your insight about Korea. That is a stark contrast to my experience here in the states. I also think you brought up a really good point about about grades just being a number/ place holder. It does not specify how or what a student needs to improve on.

  5. Grades are not the ultimate way of assessment of a person’s capability. Yes, definitely it some time to assess whether the student is learning/ grasping what is taught in the class, school, etc. But being in postmodernist world grades are a reflection of our ‘achievements’. For instance, admission to graduate school is subject to GRE scores and GPA, etc.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *