Historical Methods Fall 14
Historiography for Grads@VT
  • Syllabus
  • Complete Comments
  • Contributors
RSS
September 28, 2014

“…in accordance with the traditions of cat lore:” An Untrained Historian’s View of Cultural Anthropology

I have long nursed a soft spot for ethnographies, which has led me to the false belief that I enjoy anthropology. As an undergrad, I took an introductory anthropology course. From what I recall, there was a lot of talk … Continue reading →

saraevenson Historical Methods Assignment, History 5104

September 28, 2014

From Text to Context, from symbols to culture

Geertz starts with Balinese cockfight to illustrate local culture in Bali; Darnton takes the story of cat massacre as the epitome of French society in 18th century. I believe they may be the good examples of, in Cronon’s word, “storytelling” as they are vivid and lifelike and keep to be informative. I especially enjoy the […]

hungyin

September 28, 2014

Culture Shock and “The Great Cat Massacre”

 For historians encountering a past society through the medium of documentary sources there is – or ought to be – the same sense of ‘culture…

Claire G.

September 27, 2014

Of Cats and Men

As disturbing and horrific as the 1730’s tale of the Paris cat massacre was it highlights a complex mission of the historian – to look…

davidatkins Atkins, Darnton, Geertz, History

September 27, 2014

“Winks upon winks upon winks”

“Once human behavior is seen as…symbolic action—action which, like phonation in speech, pigment in painting, line in writing, or sonance in music…– the question as to whether culture is patterned conduct or a frame of mind, or even the two somehow mixed together loses sense…The thing to ask is what their import is…” (Geertz, “Thick Description,” […]

picasso13

September 27, 2014

“Winks upon winks upon winks”

“Once human behavior is seen as…symbolic action—action which, like phonation in speech, pigment in painting, line in writing, or sonance in music…– the question as to whether culture is patterned conduct or a frame of mind, or even the two somehow mixed together loses sense…The thing to ask is what their import is…” (Geertz, “Thick Description,” […]

picasso13

September 27, 2014

Culture, Anthropology and Sitting

Last Fall I traveled to South Korea. And when I returned home, I could barely walk…and it wasn’t from the amount of ‘trekking’ around Seoul and Gwang Ju and the Yellow Sea that gave me the pain in my legs … Continue reading →

faithskiles

September 27, 2014

Thoughts From My Soap Box Pulpit…

I have always viewed myself as somewhat of a material cultures kind of historian with a bit of oral history, public historian thrown in for good measure. I started amassing military items and collectibles from the age of four and began seriously talking to/interviewing veterans from the “Great War” through Vietnam since I was old […]

Tiny Week 2: History past: Historical Thinking/Historiography

September 26, 2014

Getting Cultured

The readings for this week have been especially useful to me by defining (or, giving a variety of definitions) for culture and cultural history. I say this because I am pretty sure after finishing the readings that I never really had a specific idea of what cultural history actually was. I have been lumping this […]

Carmen Bolt

September 25, 2014

Everybody Wants To Be A Cat (Or Maybe Not…)

When I first read the title of one of this week’s readings, I first gasped in horror then covered little Robert’s eyes as best I could. The Great Cat Massacre: now that sounds like something Robert and I both would enjoy (hmm… not so much). Needless to say, I wasn’t too terribly excited to begin this particular(…)

laura

«‹ 5 6 7 8 ›»

#gradhistf14tweets

My Tweets

RSS Recent Comments

  • Comment on Animals, Agency, and History by Tiny December 2, 2014
    Hey Laura, After hearing about how you plan on writing about the agency of dogs in the Great War, I now have a better understanding and grasp of your subject matter. I am a little surprised to read that you are questioning animals having agency in hist... Continue reading →
    Tiny
  • Comment on Rosie, Buddy, Agency and History by Tiny December 2, 2014
    Hi Faith, As usual you provided a great piece of writing in my opinion. I always look forward to your posts because they seem to make me think back to personal experiences of my own in many cases. In this post, I was taken back to many different memories of all of my four legged […]
    Tiny
  • Comment on Human Exceptionalism by Tiny December 2, 2014
    Hey David, I was glad to see that I was not the only one in the class that was wondering about animals and their agency or interaction with humans. This week's reading were very eye opening, as I had never really looked at the theory that we were just animals ourselves, having evolved to our […]
    Tiny
  • Comment on Lying down with the dogs by Claire G. December 2, 2014
    Hi Carmen, So do you see agency as a continuum, with natural disasters, urban landscapes, and other non-living shapers of history on one end and humans on the other? Claire Continue reading →
    Claire G.
  • Comment on Animals in History by Claire G. December 2, 2014
    Hi Sara, I was also pleased that we did this reading after "On Deep History and the Brain," because integrating animals into the study of history requires interdisciplinarity including psychology and the natural sciences. What do you think about how both week's readings position people in relation to other beings and forces? (Also, I think […]
    Claire G.

Recent Posts

  • Animals in History
  • Animals Equal Agency
  • Human Exceptionalism
  • Animals as subjects
  • Lying down with the dogs

Meta

  • Log in
  • Entries feed
  • Comments feed
  • WordPress.org

Categories

  • About Me
  • agency
  • agenda
  • animal kingdom
  • anthropology
  • Atkins
  • biology
  • blogging
  • Cronon
  • Darnton
  • Deep History
  • Eley
  • Enlightenment
  • Foucault
  • Geertz
  • Gender
  • Historical Methods Assignment
  • historiography
  • History
  • History 5104
  • interdisciplinary
  • Joan W Scott
  • Microhistory
  • Net
  • Power Relationships
  • present
  • Smail
  • Social History
  • Steedman
  • Storytelling
  • Tanaka
  • Thompson
  • Tosh
  • Uncategorized
  • Walker
  • Week 2: History past: Historical Thinking/Historiography
  • Weinberger

Archives

  • December 2014
  • November 2014
  • October 2014
  • September 2014
  • August 2014

↑

Historical Methods Fall 14
© Historical Methods Fall 14 2022
Powered by WordPress • Themify WordPress Themes