This post takes a “big picture” view of the siege of Leningrad, while also including lots of significant detail. You’ve found a good array of primary materials and I especially like the photograph from Piskarevskaia. It’s an incredible place, and the scale of those berms really brings the staggering loss of life into perspective.
Monthly Archives: October 2013
Comment on No Cost Could be Too High by A. Nelson
I like how you connect the significance of battles such as Kursk and the level of sacrifice during the war to Soviet security perspectives in the postwar period. Nicely done!
Comment on Katyn Forest Massacre by A. Nelson
This post complements Cara’s post on Katyn very nicely. (http://blogs.lt.vt.edu/carastombock/2013/10/20/soviet-deception-in-the-katyn-forest-massacre/). Including the material about Gorbachev makes this especially valuable.
Comment on For the Love of War by A. Nelson
Thanks so much for posting on this topic, and for linking to the recording of Temnaia noch’. Also, check out this reading of “Wait for me” (http://www.soviethistory.org/index.php?page=subject&show=audio&SubjectID=1943romance&Year=1943&navi=byYear), which is two-hanky poem for sure.
Comment on Minority Deportation After World War Two by A. Nelson
I agree with Ben. There’s lots of important material in this post. And the legacy of these deportations would be far-reaching. Just a quick point of clarification – the deportations mainly occurred during the war (1943-44)
Comment on Soviet Deception in the Katyn Forest Massacre by Ben Midas
I also agree, the formatting worked really well in this post. I remember an article I read about a year ago about the Katyn Massacre. It’s a pretty interesting read.
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/europe/poland/9535828/US-hushed-up-Katyn-massacre.html
Comment on The Gold is Back in the Red Army by Ben Midas
I really liked this post. As I was reading it, I thought back to several posts a few weeks ago about Order no. 1 and how several comrade-classmates felt that the order made the army ineffective. What did the reintroduction of ranks mean for the sentiments behind Order no. 1? How did the government reconcile a rigid rank system with the basic ideas on which the Soviet Union was founded? Did they even try to explain it, or did they even have to in the face of the German invasion?
Comment on Minority Deportation After World War Two by Ben Midas
Great post! These deportations are incredibly important because they continue to impact the Caucasus even today. You did a great job in highlighting the difference between the stated intentions and their deadly realities. This topic will come up again when we reach Khrushchev’s de-stalinization efforts, when we do, try to keep in mind the brutality of these deportations as a part of the Stalinist legacy.
Comment on For the Love of War by Ben Midas
Great post on a topic I haven’t thought to much about. As other comrade-classmates have pointed out, love can be a powerful motivator in wartime. How did this kind of love play into the state’s efforts to create bourgeois family values in terms of motherhood and child rearing?
Comment on Cominternminated by Ben Midas
Great post on an interesting topic. How did the dissolution of the Comintern highlight some of the ironies in Stalin’s government? What did it mean for various communist groups abroad?